Are we victim blaming?


February 4, 2026

"I no longer believe that infidelity is the worse thing that can happen to a marriage."

—Nancy Pickard (from this week's podcast episode)

Victim Blaming?

This comment was posted on Spotify following the release of our most recent episode, Deciding to Stay in Your Marriage: The Involved Partner:

“‘how they each contributed’ — bullshit. Victim blaming the betrayed partner. Unsubscribed.”

I wish I could talk with this person directly. Critics rarely reach out personally, and reactions are often triggered by a single phrase rather than the fuller context. Still, behind comments like this are real people, real pain, and real experiences of betrayal.

So let me be clear—again.

We do not believe that betrayed partners share responsibility for an affair. We do not believe that an affair automatically indicates problems in the relationship. Sometimes it does; sometimes it doesn’t. And even when a marriage has struggled, those struggles are never an excuse for infidelity. Other choices could always have been made.

If a betrayed partner chooses to stay in the marriage, healing requires more than identifying who caused the betrayal. It also involves honestly examining the marriage that existed before it and taking responsibility for one’s own role in rebuilding what was damaged.

A betrayed partner may be the only victim of the affair itself. But if the marriage had faltered, they may not have been the only one wounded within it. Acknowledging that distinction is not about assigning fault—it’s about making healing possible.

Podcast Episode #41: Deciding to Stay: The Injured Partner

My interview with Nancy Pickard, a certified Relational Life Institute coach, about the unique considerations of the betrayed partner who chooses to stay in their marriage.

Podcast Episode #40: Deciding to Leave Your Marriage: Emotions, Relationships, and Religion

Sharon Barbour, Affair Healing counselor and coach, joins me in this second part of the "Deciding to Leave" series. In this episode, we discuss grief, shame, coparenting, starting new relationships, and the religious viewpoints that some have to consider.

Rising Phoenix's Penultimate Post

In her second-to-last post, Rising Phoenix writes about The Last Three Years and the Marriage We Built.

But this isn't the last we'll hear from Rising. Stay tuned for updates!

If you had an affair and need help, I'd love to connect with you. Tell me your story and I'll give you some personal feedback. I've been there. No judgement. No catch.

275 Medical Dr #3622, Carmel, IN 46082
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Affair Healing

A weekly newsletter offering affair recovery help through articles, podcasts, downloads, and recommended resources. Presented by Tim Tedder, an affair recovery counselor for over 20 years.

Read more from Affair Healing

March 4 2026 "The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place." —George Bernard Shaw Good Communication is a Learnable Skill There’s a certain kind of silence that settles into a relationship when both people believe they’ve already said what needed to be said. He thinks, I told you I was sorry. She thinks, You never really talked to me about it. He believes the conversation is over because words were spoken. She knows it hasn’t even started.Most couples...

February 25, 2026 "When you blame others, you give up your power to change." —Robert Anthony When Blame Feels Justified In 2018, Starbucks faced a major public backlash after two Black men were arrested while waiting in a Philadelphia store. The arrests were captured on video and went viral. Public anger was justified. There were calls for boycotts. The situation clearly reflected a systemic failure.The CEO at the time, Kevin Johnson, could have blamed the individual employee, the police...

February 18, 2026 Do you have a recommendation, story, or question to submit? I'd love to hear from you! "In my eyes, I’m a winner because I was able to persevere right through." —Chloe Kim, Olympic silver winner When We Miss the Prize I remember, during my sophomore year of college, envisioning my future. I had it all mapped out: the man I would become, the marriage I would build, the kind of father I would be, a meaningful career—a life that felt steady, honorable, and whole. That dream...